Site Navigation

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
FAQ

Heavenly Cheesecakes & Bakery

"Made Fresh in St. Augustine- Call Ahead for a Slice of Heaven."

About Us

Heavenly Cheesecakes & Bakery in St. Augustine, FL, is your top destination for exquisite, locally made baked goods, proudly serving nearby communities like Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee, Jacksonville, and St. Johns. Renowned for our wide variety of decadent cheesecakes and handcrafted desserts, we use only the finest ingredients to create treats that are as beautiful as they are delicious.
We specialize in custom orders to make your celebrations and personal indulgences truly special. All pre-orders must be placed by phone only, ensuring we give each order the personal attention it deserves. Please note, we do not offer catering or delivery services. Call ahead to reserve your favorites and guarantee availability for your next sweet craving.

Areas Served

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

At Heavenly Cheesecake & Bakery, indulgence meets artistry with a wide selection of decadent cheesecakes crafted to perfection—featuring over 30 unique flavors to satisfy every craving. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply treating yourself, custom orders are always welcome to make your dessert dreams come true. Be sure to explore their delightful array of holiday and seasonal items, thoughtfully created to bring a festive touch to every celebration.

Our Services include:

At Heavenly Cheesecakes & Bakery, we take pride in crafting our delectable treats right here in St. Augustine, FL. Each dessert is made locally to ensure freshness and quality in every bite. From rich, creamy cheesecakes to irresistible pastries and baked goods, everything we offer is prepared with care and attention to detail.
While we do not offer catering or delivery services, we gladly accept pre-orders by phone only. Calling ahead is the exclusive way to reserve your favorites and guarantee availability for your special occasion or sweet craving.

Our Products include:

Over 30 flavors available
Cakes come in 6" and 9"
Featured Flavor: Zesty Key Lime
Chocolate-dipped cheesecake pops
Assorted pastries
Artisan breads- Sourdough Daily and Specialty Rotating Flavors Too
Gooey cinnamon rolls
Gourmet homemade quiche

Testimonials

On 7/13/2026 Langdon Wood had this to say:
Best cheesecake I have ever had! It's like a speakeasy for cheesecakes, in the best way possible, connected to a wonderful produce stand and to a great seafood market (Kyle's Seafood)! It's a one stop shop for the meal of your life! Ill be back for the rest of my life! All their desserts are truly "Heavenly"!!

On 7/11/2026 Brittany had this to say:
Best freaking cheesecake I’ve ever had in my life!!

On 7/4/2026 Cynthia West had this to say:
I stopped in for the first time today and knew I found a great spot. We picked up cinnamon rolls, a peach turnover, guava and cream cheese turnover and loaf of sourdough bread. The turnovers didn’t even make it home, they were incredible! Everyone loved the cinnamon rolls and the sourdough bread was amazing for making eggs in a basket. I’ll have to make another trip to try out the cheesecake. Awesome bakery!

On 6/19/2026 Noel Seaton had this to say:
Hands down the best cheesecake! My only regret is only getting a few mini cheesecakes instead of the big ones. I will definitely be returning to get more!

On 5/2/2026 Kim Reid had this to say:
I bought the strawberry cheesecake, it was absolutely delicious. Not very sweet, just perfect.👌

Contact Us

Heavenly Cheesecakes & Bakery
3874 N Ponce De Leon Blvd St. Augustine, FL 32084
Phone: (904) 217-7284
Email: heavenlycheesecakesbakery@gmail.com

Kyle's Seafood and Currie's Produce

Where To Find Us

Our Hours

Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM

FAQ

How can I place a pre-order?

All pre-orders must be placed by phone and in-store only. This is the only way to reserve items in advance, as we do not accept online orders. Please call us directly to secure your desserts.

Are your cheesecakes made fresh daily?

Yes! All of our cheesecakes and baked goods are made fresh locally with quality ingredients.

What cheesecake flavors do you offer?

We take pride in our extensive selection of cheesecakes, offering both 6" and 9" sizes to suit any occasion. Indulge in our diverse array of over 30 flavors, including customer favorites like Key Lime, Chocolate, and the classic New York. Our seasonal specialties ensure there's always a delightful new taste to explore. Whether you're satisfying a craving or planning a celebration, our cheesecakes are the perfect treat for every palate!

Do you have gluten-free or special dietary options?

We do offer select options—please call ahead to check availability or place a special order.

What other baked goods do you offer?

In addition to cheesecakes, we offer cinnamon rolls, pastries, fresh breads, and baked-daily quiche.