How can I place a pre-order?

All pre-orders must be placed by phone and in-store only. This is the only way to reserve items in advance, as we do not accept online orders. Please call us directly to secure your desserts.

Are your cheesecakes made fresh daily?

Yes! All of our cheesecakes and baked goods are made fresh locally with quality ingredients.

What cheesecake flavors do you offer?

We take pride in our extensive selection of cheesecakes, offering both 6\" and 9\" sizes to suit any occasion. Indulge in our diverse array of over 30 flavors, including customer favorites like Key Lime, Chocolate, and the classic New York. Our seasonal specialties ensure there's always a delightful new taste to explore. Whether you're satisfying a craving or planning a celebration, our cheesecakes are the perfect treat for every palate!

Do you have gluten-free or special dietary options?

We do offer select options—please call ahead to check availability or place a special order.

What other baked goods do you offer?

In addition to cheesecakes, we offer cinnamon rolls, pastries, fresh breads, and baked-daily quiche.

Heavenly Cheesecakes & Bakery - St. Augustine, FL

Made Fresh in St. Augustine- Call Ahead for a Slice of Heaven.

Over 30 flavors available

Cakes come in 6" and 9"

Featured Flavor: Zesty Key Lime

Chocolate-dipped cheesecake pops

Assorted pastries

Artisan breads- Sourdough Daily and Specialty Rotating Flavors Too

Over 30 flavors available

Cakes come in 6" and 9"

Featured Flavor: Zesty Key Lime

Chocolate-dipped cheesecake pops

Assorted pastries

Artisan breads- Sourdough Daily and Specialty Rotating Flavors Too

Established in 2020

Located in St. Augustine, FL

- Liz W. 9/30/2026

"Stopped in yesterday and found that Walter was just packing a loaf of Datil Pepper Sourdough 🌶! Couldn't resist & it is so good! The snickerdoodle cookies were a delicious treat! Love any cheesecake!"